New England Lazy Lady’s Lobster
Writer: Cape Cod Life Publications
New England Lazy Lady’s Lobster
Writer: Cape Cod Life Publications

Servings: 8 as a small plate, each getting ½ lobster
Ingredients
For the lobster:
- 4 x 1-1/2 steamed/boiled female lobsters so you get tomalley and coral
- For the tomalley tarragon cream:
- ½ minced large shallot
- 1 stick salted butter
- ¼ cup white wine
- 1 tsp ground white pepper
- 1 bunch fresh tarragon leaves only
- ½ cup heavy cream
- 2 tsp of salt
- All of the green tomalley from the cooked lobsters
For the bourbon coral (roe):
- All of the red coral from the cooked lobsters coarsely chopped
- 2 TBS minced shallot
- 4 TBS salted butter
- ¼ Cup bourbon
Instructions
For the lobster:
- Steam lobsters and carefully split bodies down the middle using heavy duty kitchen scissors.
- Separate green tomalley and red coral and place in two bowls.
- Remove claws, crack and carefully remove meat so as not to damage it. Remove shells from tail, leaving the bottom fins intact.
- Clean the two halves of the lobster head shell with water, leaving the antenna/eyes in place.
Chef tip: Use kitchen shears to trim loose pieces of tail to make look clean.
For the tomalley tarragon cream:
- In a small sauté pan on medium low heat, sweat the shallots in butter. Careful to not overcook, they should be translucent, not caramelized.
- Add the white pepper, followed by the white wine and simmer for 1 minute. Add all the green tomalley from the lobsters. Let cook for an additional minute.
- Place the cooked mixture into a blender. Add the heavy cream, salt, and tarragon leaves that have been stripped from the stems. Blend until smooth, and then put aside in a container.
Chef tip: If you see any black on the edges of the Tomalley just sauté until it turns green.
For the bourbon coral (roe):
- In a small sauté pan, sweat the shallots in butter. After 1 minute, add the chopped red coral.
- Add the bourbon and flambee until the alcohol burns off, about 20 seconds. Let simmer for an additional minute, remove from heat and put aside in a separate bowl.
Chef tip: If you see any black on the edges of the coral just sauté until it turns red.
To serve:
- Fill bottom of plate with a thin layer of the green tomalley tarragon sauce.
- Place a tail on top of the sauce, then ½ the carapace (head) above the tail with the antenna.
- Arrange the knuckle meat and claw meat to look like a lobster laying on its side.
- Take the red coral / shallot mixture and sprinkle it around the lobster for contrast and texture.
Notes
Recipe provided by Anna Rossi.
Anna is an Emmy Award-winning Lifestyle Host and TV Personality. She brings an authentic connection to food, travel, and the art of gathering as a culinary leader, food writer, recipe developer, brand ambassador, and spokesperson. Her culinary and TV journey began when she competed alongside her husband, AJ, on MasterChef USA. She has since become a celebrated home cook, developing original recipes and hosting cooking shows featured nationwide.
Anna and her family have a strong connection to and love for Cape Cod spending much of the summer in Osterville. A special thanks to Anna and AJ for the incredible feast they created to celebrate the flavors of Cape Cod’s “Local Summer.” - Julie Craven Wagner
Tried this recipe?Let us know how it was!