Cape Cod Life's Annual Readers' Choice Awards Presented by 2023 Best of Food & Drink Cape Cod & the Islands Presented by Brought to you by Food & Drink Categories Bakery Brewery/Distillery Burger Chowder Cocktails Coffee Fried Clams Ice Cream Lobster Roll Pizza Sandwiches Seafood Market Best Bakery Gold Woolfie’s Bakery Dennis Port | Mid Cape The Black Dog Water St. Bakery Vineyard Haven | Martha's Vineyard Born & Bread Nantucket Nantucket | Nantucket Eat Cake 4 Breakfast Bakery Brewster | Lower Cape PB Boulangerie Bistro South Wellfleet | Outer Cape Maison Villatte Falmouth | Upper Cape Silver Wicked Island Bakery Nantucket | Nantucket Beth’s Bakery & Café Sandwich | Upper Cape Back Door Donuts Oak Bluffs | Martha's Vineyard Provincetown Portuguese Bakery Provincetown | Outer Cape Pain D’Avignon Hyannis | Mid Cape Cottage Street Bakery Orleans | Lower Cape Best Brewery/Distillery Gold Hog Island Beer Co. Orleans | Lower Cape Cape Cod Beer Hyannis | Mid Cape Bad Martha Farmer’s Brewery & Tasting Room-Edgartown Edgartown | Martha's Vineyard Provincetown Brewing Co. Provincetown | Outer Cape Bad Martha Farmer’s Brewery & Tasting Room-East Falmouth East Falmouth | Upper Cape Cisco Brewers Nantucket | Nantucket Silver First Crush Winery Harwich | Lower Cape Truro Vineyards of Cape Cod North Truro | Outer Cape Triple Eight Distillery Nantucket | Nantucket Devil’s Purse Brewing Company South Dennis | Mid Cape Naukabout Brewing Company Mashpee | Upper Cape Offshore Ale Company Oak Bluffs | Martha's Vineyard Best Burger Gold The Restaurant & Pub Next Door Dennis Port | Mid Cape Stubbys Nantucket | Nantucket the knack Orleans | Lower Cape Local 186 Provincetown | Outer Cape Atria’s Brick Cellar Bar Edgartown | Martha's Vineyard Liam Maguire’s Irish Pub Falmouth | Upper Cape Silver Jason’s Tavern South Dennis | Mid Cape Brotherhood of Thieves Nantucket | Nantucket Local Break Eastham | Outer Cape Chapoquoit Grill West Falmouth | Upper Cape Mom & Pops Burgers Chatham | Lower Cape Offshore Ale Company Oak Bluffs | Martha's Vineyard Best Chowder Gold The SeaGrille Nantucket | Nantucket Martha’s Vineyard Chowder Company Oak Bluffs | Martha's Vineyard JT’s Seafood Restaurant Brewster | Lower Cape Landfall Restaurant Woods Hole | Upper Cape Captain Parker’s Pub West Yarmouth | Mid Cape Lobster Pot Provincetown | Outer Cape Silver PJ’s Family Restaurant Wellfleet | Outer Cape Menemsha Fish Market Chilmark | Martha's Vineyard Skipper Chowder House South Yarmouth | Mid Cape Chatham Squire Chatham | Lower Cape The Lobster Trap Bourne | Upper Cape Brotherhood of Thieves Nantucket | Nantucket Best Cocktails Gold Mezzeterranean Provincetown | Outer Cape Ocean Edge Resort & Golf Club Brewster | Lower Cape Encore Bistro & Bar Dennis | Mid Cape Nancy’s Restaurant & Snack Bar Oak Bluffs | Martha's Vineyard Brotherhood of Thieves Nantucket | Nantucket Chart Room Cataumet | Upper Cape Silver Atlantic Fish & Chop House Edgartown | Martha's Vineyard The Club Car Nantucket | Nantucket Alberto’s Ristorante Hyannis | Mid Cape The Seal Pub and Café Harwich | Lower Cape Courtyard Restaurant & Pub Cataumet | Upper Cape Harbor Lounge Provincetown | Outer Cape Best Coffee Gold Great Awakening Coffee House Hyannis | Mid Cape The Hub of Nantucket Nantucket | Nantucket Cape Cod Coffee Mashpee | Upper Cape Snowy Owl Coffee Roasters Brewster | Lower Cape Joe Coffee Provincetown | Outer Cape Mocha Mott’s-Oak Bluffs Oak Bluffs | Martha's Vineyard Silver Wired Puppy Provincetown | Outer Cape Three Fins Coffee Roasters West Dennis | Mid Cape Hot Chocolate Sparrow Orleans | Lower Cape Mocha Mott’s-Vineyard Haven Vineyard Haven | Martha's Vineyard Coffee Obsession Falmouth | Upper Cape Roastd General Store Nantucket | Nantucket Best Fried Clams Gold Arnold’s Lobster & Clam Bar Eastham | Outer Cape Giordano’s Restaurant Oak Bluffs | Martha's Vineyard Seafood Sam’s Sandwich Sandwich | Upper Cape Sayle’s Seafood Nantucket | Nantucket JT’s Seafood Restaurant Brewster | Lower Cape Kream ‘N Kone West Dennis | Mid Cape Silver Kream N’ Kone Restaurant Chatham | Lower Cape Spanky’s Clam Shack Hyannis | Mid Cape Faregrounds Restaurant & Pudley’s Pub Nantucket | Nantucket PJ’s Family Restaurant Wellfleet | Outer Cape The Net Result Fish Market Vineyard Haven | Martha's Vineyard Seafood Sam’s Falmouth Falmouth | Upper Cape Best Ice Cream Gold Sundae School Ice Cream – Harwich Port Harwich Port | Lower Cape Four Seas Ice Cream Centerville | Mid Cape Nauset Ice Cream North Eastham | Outer Cape Mad Martha’s Ice Cream-Oak Bluffs Oak Bluffs | Martha's Vineyard The Juice Bar Nantucket | Nantucket Somerset Creamery Cataumet | Upper Cape Silver Ben & Bill Chocolate Emporium – Oak Bluffs Oak Bluffs | Martha's Vineyard Lewis Brothers Homemade Ice Cream Provincetown | Outer Cape Smitty’s Homemade Ice Cream East Falmouth | Upper Cape Island Kitchen Nantucket | Nantucket Sundae School Ice Cream – Dennis Port Dennis Port | Mid Cape Ice Cream Café Orleans | Lower Cape Best Lobster Roll Gold The Raw Bar at Popponesset Marketplace Mashpee | Upper Cape JT’s Seafood Restaurant Brewster | Lower Cape Sesuit Harbor Cafe Dennis | Mid Cape Lobster Pot Provincetown | Outer Cape Lookout Tavern Oak Bluffs | Martha's Vineyard CRU Oyster Bar Nantucket | Nantucket Silver Brant Point Grill at the White Elephant Nantucket | Nantucket Spanky’s Clam Shack Hyannis | Mid Cape Brax Landing Restaurant Harwich Port | Lower Cape The Canteen Provincetown | Outer Cape Grace Episcopal Church Vineyard Haven | Martha's Vineyard The Lobster Trap Bourne | Upper Cape Best Pizza Gold Palio Pizzeria Hyannis | Mid Cape Paul’s Pizza & Seafood Falmouth | Upper Cape George’s Pizza House Harwich Port | Lower Cape Spiritus Pizza Provincetown | Outer Cape Giordano’s Restaurant Oak Bluffs | Martha's Vineyard Pi Pizzeria Nantucket | Nantucket Silver Crisp Osterville | Mid Cape Sophie T’s Pizza Nantucket | Nantucket Simply Divine Pizza Co. Falmouth | Upper Cape Pleasant Lake Pizza Shark Harwich | Lower Cape The Red Barn Pizza Eastham | Outer Cape Porto Pizza Vineyard Haven | Martha's Vineyard Best Sandwiches Gold Café Alfresco Brewster | Lower Cape Dennis Public Market Dennis | Mid Cape Far Land Provisions Provincetown | Outer Cape 7a Foods West Tisbury | Martha's Vineyard Something Natural Nantucket | Nantucket Café Chew Sandwich | Upper Cape Silver Chatham Cookware Café Chatham | Lower Cape Sam’s Deli Eastham | Outer Cape West Falmouth Market Falmouth | Upper Cape Waterside Market Vineyard Haven | Martha's Vineyard Henry Jr. Sandwich Shop Nantucket | Nantucket Holly’s Deli West Dennis | Mid Cape Best Seafood Market Gold Menemsha Fish Market Chilmark | Martha's Vineyard Glidden’s Island Seafood Nantucket | Nantucket Nauset Fish & Lobster Pool Orleans | Lower Cape Cape Fish and Lobster Hyannis | Mid Cape Mac’s Seafood Market Provincetown Provincetown | Outer Cape The Clam Man Falmouth | Upper Cape Silver Sayle’s Seafood Nantucket | Nantucket Falmouth Fish Market Falmouth | Upper Cape Mac’s Chatham Fish & Lobster Chatham | Lower Cape Mac’s Market and Kitchen Eastham | Outer Cape Edgartown Meat & Fish Market Edgartown | Martha's Vineyard Andrea’s West Yarmouth Fish & Lobster West Yarmouth | Mid Cape Keep exploring these other best of categories! Dining Lodging Shopping Things To Do